Saturday, July 29, 2017

New Painting: "Unraveled"

I have finally put the finishing touches on a new/old painting that I titled today: "Unraveled".  As with all my paintings this one went through many stages to reach its current state.  The oil stick happened mid-way through.  Once I discovered it (quite by accident I must say) I liked it immediately. It gives texture and I do not have to endure the smell of various chemicals in the studio.  I am excited to be saying this painting finished.  (phewwwwww)

Above:  Unraveled Oil and oilstick on canvas 36" x 46" c. Triada Samaras 2017


Stay tuned for something new:  a photo-intaglio of an image of this painting.  I had the good fortune to work with Printmaker Julie Harris yesterday who coached me through my first print....and I liked that process. 

Thursday, July 20, 2017

A Call for Self-Photographs from Artist Julie Harris and Her Breast Cancer Art Installation Project

My artist friend and Kean University colleague Julie Harris has begun a fabulous new body of art depicting the statistics of breast cancer....


Below are her words from her Facebook page.
"All ladies, 18 and up! Please consider participating in my breast cancer project! 
I'm seeking women unaffected by breast cancer as well as breast cancer survivors to be included in a large scale art installation utilizing anonymous high resolution, 300 dpi, photographs of themselves, clavicle to belly button.ors to be included in a large scale art installation utilizing anonymous high resolution, 300 dpi, photographs of themselves, clavicle to belly button. 
The images can be taken by yourself if you have a good camera, then emailed or messaged to me! Please message me for details if you or anybody you know of might be interested! The show will reflect the staggering statistics that one in eight women will develop breast cancer in her lifetime. Thanks for reading and I would be honored to have you included in my art project! I've got 18 women already!"  (Julie Harris)  

Below Image:  Artwork by Artist, Julie Harris



Wednesday, June 21, 2017

Puck Quartet Bartok Clip: String Quartet No. 1


Hello everyone!

Below is a Bartok clip from the Puck Quartet Facebook Page.  

I quote them here:
Bartok clip from last summer! Puck is very excited to be heading back to beautiful California this week for the St. Lawrence String QuartetChamber Music Seminar. We'll watch our backs for turkeys... #puckquartet #corefuljohnson


Performed on June 25, 2016 in Bing Concert Hall in Palo Alto, California

These talented and fierce musicians must be seen and experienced live to be fully appreciated!  For the full piece please go here:  http://www.puckquartet.com/listen/

The Puck Quartet
Lily Holgate, Violin
KennethTrotter, Violin
Katharine Dryden, Viola 
Liam Veuve, Cello


From the Rhinebeck Chamber Music Society page where they performed recently:

"The Puck Quartet formed in 2013 at Purchase College Conservatory of Music, and in 2015 was one of four quartets from around the country personally selected by renowned violinist Robert Mann to participate in the fourth annual Robert Mann String Quartet Institute at the Manhattan School of Music. In the spring of 2014, the quartet, supported by an award from the Marx Family Foundation, gave the world premiere performance of Ascension, a work by composer Jason Eckardt. The Puck Quartet has participated in masterclasses with the Miro Quartet, Decoda Chamber Ensemble, and members of the American, Brentano, and Tokyo Quartets. They have also participated in several festivals including the Beethoven Institute at Mannes and the Saint Lawrence String Quartet Institute at Stanford University. Recent engagements include a performance in a lecture-concert series at Metropolitan Hospital in New York City, and a recital as a featured artist in the inaugural season of the Under The Spire concert series at Trinity Episcopal Church in Southport, Connecticut."

"Members of the ensemble have performed with groups such as NOVUS NY, Mimesis Ensemble, and Canyonlands New Music Ensemble, and have participated in festivals and concert series across the country including the Manchester Music Festival, the North Jersey Chamber Music Society, the Louis Moreau Institute for New Music in New Orleans, and Capital City Concerts in Montpelier, Vermont."

"The quartet’s principal mentors include Julia Lichten, David Geber, Deborah Buck, and Carmit Zori. Members of the quartet hold degrees from SUNY Purchase, Cleveland Institute of Music, New York University, and Yale University."


Tuesday, June 20, 2017

Puck Quartet performs at SFS in New York City and the Rhinebeck Chamber Music Society

Hello everyone!


Above:  Puck Quartet
From Left to Right:   Lily Holgate, Katharine, Dryden, Liam Veuve, Kenneth Trotter

I have had the good fortune to see and hear three stellar performances in New York City this past spring.  For the first of these, I heard the preview concert of the Puck Quartet who performed two out of three of their pieces at SFS in New York City a week before their performance at the Rhinebeck Chamber Music Society on Mother's day: the Shostakovich String Quartet No. 8, and the Bartok String Quartet No. 1.  These fierce musical pieces were handled extremely well by the four accomplished musicians making up the Puck Quartet:
Lily Holgate, Violin
KennethTrotter, Violin
Katharine Dryden, Viola 
Liam Veuve, Cello
making this evening a memorable one, and this quartet one to watch for in the near future!

The pieces were first introduced by members of the quartet who gave the audience a welcome insight into the reason for their existence including their original inspirations and their historical contexts  Shostakovih's wrenching String Quartet No. 8 was then performed in a compelling and provocative manner by the Puck Quartet, allowing the audience to fully experience the depths of Shostakovich's emotional and political despair as he composed this piece. The Bartok String Quartet No. 1 followed with the quartet members handling its complexity and sophisticated musical architecture admirably.  A week later in Rhinebeck, NY on Mother's Day, Sebastian Lambertz joined them, performing on clarinet with the Puck Quartert: Mozart's Clarinet Quintet in A Major.

Above:  Sebastian Lambertz
Below I include some of the text from the Rhinebeck Chamber Music Festival website written by Gary Lachmund as well as the link to a clip of the Puck Quartet playing from their newly created Facebook Page
Bartok Clip (performed by Puck Quartet)
https://www.facebook.com/puckquartet


Next up for the Puck Quartet:  
Puck is very excited to be heading back to beautiful California this week for the St. Lawrence String Quartet Chamber Music Seminar at Stanford University!



From the Rhinebeck Chamber Music Society page:
"The Puck Quartet formed in 2013 at Purchase College Conservatory of Music, and in 2015 was one of four quartets from around the country personally selected by renowned violinist Robert Mann to participate in the fourth annual Robert Mann String Quartet Institute at the Manhattan School of Music. In the spring of 2014, the quartet, supported by an award from the Marx Family Foundation, gave the world premiere performance of Ascension, a work by composer Jason Eckardt. The Puck Quartet has participated in masterclasses with the Miro Quartet, Decoda Chamber Ensemble, and members of the American, Brentano, and Tokyo Quartets. They have also participated in several festivals including the Beethoven Institute at Mannes and the Saint Lawrence String Quartet Institute at Stanford University. Recent engagements include a performance in a lecture-concert series at Metropolitan Hospital in New York City, and a recital as a featured artist in the inaugural season of the Under The Spire concert series at Trinity Episcopal Church in Southport, Connecticut."

"Members of the ensemble have performed with groups such as NOVUS NY, Mimesis Ensemble, and Canyonlands New Music Ensemble, and have participated in festivals and concert series across the country including the Manchester Music Festival, the North Jersey Chamber Music Society, the Louis Moreau Institute for New Music in New Orleans, and Capital City Concerts in Montpelier, Vermont."

"The quartet’s principal mentors include Julia Lichten, David Geber, Deborah Buck, and Carmit Zori. Members of the quartet hold degrees from SUNY Purchase, Cleveland Institute of Music, New York University, and Yale University."

"The Arts Entrepreneur Sebastian Lambertz represents a new generation of musicians. He is currently experiencing an increasing interest from the international media for his innovative concepts in the field of “New Audience for Classical Music” – “Little Ant”, “Clarinet & DJ”, “Quintet for the End of Time” and projects for music and interactive technology. Sebastian is one of the “inspiring individuals in New York City”. (Epoch Times, NY)"

"Highlights in 2015 were his Lincoln Center Debut for which he was invited by the German Forum New York as well as a performance with the Grammy nominated Ensemble Imani Winds. In 2014 Sebastian Lambertz was honored twice for his musical work. In his hometown in Germany he received the “Kunstförderpreis” of the city of Neuss 2013."

"Concert tours led him to performances throughout Europe, Asia, and North America including cities like Paris, Dubrovnik, Beijing, Chengdu, Seoul, New-Delhi, Washington D.C. and New York. In Germany, he played at the Kölner Philharmonie, the Konzerthaus Berlin, the Herkulessaal München, the Tonhalle Düsseldorf, the Essener Philharmonie, the Beethovenhaus Bonn, and in the studios of the WDR Köln and the NDR Hannover. He felt especially honored when he played for German Chancellor Angela Merkel as well as resigned Chancellor Helmut Schmidt and Federal President Horst Köhler. Several tours on board of the MS Europa complete the spectrum of his exclusive concert venues."

"He collaborated with Charles Neidich, Ian Fountain, Silke Avenhaus, Nikolas and Christoph Altstädt, Brett Dean as well as members of the Scharoun Ensemble Berlin as a chamber musician. In orchestras he played under the conducters Kent Nagano, Jonathan Nott, Joseph Colaneri, Michael Sanderling, and Han-Na Chang. As a soloist, he performed with the Bergische Symphoniker."

"Sebastian Lambertz received several awards and grants. Some of the most important ones include the 3rd price at the 55. ARD International Music Competition Munich in 2006 and the scholarship of the German Music Competition in 2010."

"At the age of ten Sebastian Lambertz started playing the clarinet. He studied with Martin Spangenberg in Weimar and Ralph Manno in Cologne. Studying with Charles Neidich, he received his Professional Studies Diploma in New York as a full scholarship student at Mannes College – The New School."

PROGRAM NOTES
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756 – 1791),
Clarinet Quintet in A Major K581 (1789)

        Allegro
        Larghetto
        Menuetto
        Allegretto con Variazioni

Dmitri Shostakovich (1906 - 1975),
String Quartet #8 in c minor Op 110 (1960)

        Largo
        Allegro molto
        Allegretto
        Largo
        Largo

Intermission

Béla Bartók (1881 - 1945), String Quartet #1 Sz 40 (1909)
        Lento
        Allegretto
        Introduzione – Allegro vivace


"Mozart’s Clarinet Quintet was written for the renowned clarinet virtuoso Anton Stadler, a longtime friend of Mozart for whom he also composed his clarinet concerto, the Kegelstatt trio, and the two great arias with clarinet obbligato from his final opera La Clemenza di Tito. The clarinet family was larger then, and contained at least two instruments with slightly lower ranges than modern clarinets – the basset clarinet for which the quintet was originally written and the basset horn for the concerto. Both are strange looking instruments used today primarily in original instrument performances, but in performances on modern instruments little is lost except a few low notes."

"In terms of formal structure, the clarinet quintet is about as plain vanilla as they come – first movement in sonata form, slow movement in ternary form, traditional minuet and trio, and theme-and-variations finale. But what a wealth of material Mozart crams into this structure, and with what Mozartean elegance! It is impossible not to love this music, which must have driven Mozart’s rivals to distraction. There are passages in Mozart’s music – for instance the first ten notes of this quintet or the first nine of Eine Kleine Nachtmusik (remember the scene at the start of Amadeus!) – that sound so natural and so inevitable that one gets the sense that they have been lurking somewhere in our subconscious all along, and that all Mozart has done is to remind us of something we already knew. The ability to write music that sounds like it was discovered rather than composed borders on the miraculous."

"If Beethoven’s 16 string quartets are the best known quartet “cycle”, Dmitri Shostakovich’s 15 quartets are surely a strong runner-up. Both cycles span their composer’s maturity – first quartets written in their early thirties and last quartets in the year before their deaths – and both pushed the envelope of contemporary quartet writing."

"Also like Beethoven, Shostakovich had seen war, but Shostakovich’s war was of a ferocity unparalleled in history, costing 20 million lives in the Soviet Union alone. Virtually every family in the country had lost a loved one, and a sense of death and mourning pervades much of Shostakovich’s music. His Eighth Quartet was written in just three days in 1960, shortly after he was forced to join the Communist party and discovered that he was suffering from ALS. It contains five movements (three of which are marked “largo”), and profoundly conveys what the war meant to Shostakovich, and by extension to the Soviet people. [When the Borodin Quartet played this work for Shostakovich in his home in preparation for recording it, he broke down to such an extent that rather than asking for feedback on their interpretation the performers simply packed up their instruments and departed in silence."

"The harmonic structure of Shostakovich’s music clearly marks it as 20th century. But it relies heavily on the use of two musical forms inherited from the Baroque – counterpoint and passacaglia (variations over a fixed ground). Both techniques are used in the first movement, a slow dirge of the deepest feeling. The mood is broken by the second movement, a frenzied dance that conveys no real joy. The third, a grotesque minuet, only deepens the sense of the futility of achieving any real sense of lightness or merriment. It is a mark of Shostakovich’s genius that he could compose music that is outwardly lively and bouncy while simultaneously conveying the sense that it is all a facade. The more genuine feeling of the first movement returns in the fourth movement, a funeral march with occasional outbursts of anger. The final movement returns to counterpoint and passacaglia – both techniques used flexibly and sometimes simultaneously, with the ground shifting among the four instruments – and ends on a note of utter despair."

"In his early twenties Hungarian composer Béla Bartók became interested in folk music and began to incorporate it in his own compositions, a path that Liszt, Chopin, Dvořák, Smetana, and Grieg had already established. But Bartók was a scholar as well as a borrower, and along with his friend Zoltán Kodály spent much time collecting and analyzing folk music from throughout Eastern Europe and even as far afield as Algeria. He fled the Nazis in 1940, emigrating to New York and becoming an American citizen in 1945. Since he was known here primarily as an ethnomusicologist he encountered difficulty establishing himself as a composer and wrote relatively little, particularly after he was diagnosed with leukemia in 1942. His best known work, Concerto for Orchestra, was composed the year before his death. His oeuvre is dominated by piano and chamber music, including six string quartets (probably the third best known quartet cycle). In addition to Concerto for Orchestra, his large scale compositions include an opera, two ballets, and six concertos for solo instruments."

"Bartók’s String Quartet #1 is a memorial to an unrequited love for the violinist Stefi Geyer, for whom he had already composed a violin concerto (which she rejected). The first movement is heavily contrapuntal. But this is not the counterpoint of Bach, Mozart, or even Shostakovich, where the voices share significant thematic material. Here the four instruments move relatively independently and the common material consists primarily of wide descending intervals (often major or minor sixths) passed from instrument to instrument. If one looks for an antecedent to the sound of this counterpoint it might be to the motets of the Renaissance (albeit with a radically different harmonic language). At times voices combine, with the second violin, viola and cello working together to provide a setting for relatively lyrical material in the first violin, reversing when cello and first violin switch roles. Textures lighten and the mood briefly brightens in the second movement, built around a descending three note (long-short-short) motive. But as the movement progresses the music becomes more ominous, erupts in a state of near fury, and subsides into resignation. The finale, the longest movement of the work, is the most conservative in structure in that it is based on a single, recognizable, and even hummable theme that undergoes more or less continuous variation. It even includes a passage of traditional (and cute) counterpoint. A few moments of reflectiveness occasionally interrupt music that is optimistic, sometimes humorous, and even vaguely Hungarian."

"The string quartets of Bartók, like much of his music, make for prickly listening and are, unlike Mozart’s quintet, possible not to love. At Music Mountain, the regional temple of the string quartet, years have passed without any of Bartók’s quartets being performed. When asked about this, artistic director Nicholas Gordon (son of Jacques Gordon, the founder of Music Mountain) replied “I don’t like Bartók, and it seems our audience doesn’t either”. This afternoon you will have the opportunity to judge for yourselves."

Gary Lachmund

Saturday, April 29, 2017

Impeachment or.....

Some emotions make me feel very off balance, like I might lose my lunch and much more. My mind struggles to straighten out the pieces of the road in front of me....
I wait for the passing of the storm. And I pray for impeachment or impalement or improvement.

Sunday, April 9, 2017

The Gowanus Canal Clean-Up is (More or Less) on Schedule


From the CG CORD Blog:

March 2017 Gowanus Canal CAG General Meeting Summary

The March Gowanus Canal CAG General meeting was held at the St Mary's houses on Carroll Street on its regular last Tuesday of the month at 6:30 PM


In attendance were EPA Project Manager, Christos Tsiamis and Legal Counsel, Brian Carr as well as representatives from the Army Corp of Engineers,  NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) and US Fish and Wildlife Service. They were there to explain their role as some of the Trustees in a program called the National Resource Damage Assessment (NRDA)  which helps neighborhoods/communities recover monetary damages suffered from environmental accidents/disasters/situations.


We were given an update by both EPA representatives:

--4th Street Basin pilot study/design is 50% complete.

--The First Street Basin may begin by late fall early 2018.

--The 5th Street basin has had some work done. some data collected and that data is currently being reviewed. There should be more updates regarding this basin at the next general meeting.
(edit) 


Part of the discussion turned to some of the financial facts of our Gowanus Superfund Project. Lately, there has been quite a bit of buzz regarding the Superfund status of the Canal since the new administration has taken over.

There have been articles claiming that the funding is endangered--indeed the project could be endangered.

During the course of last week's meeting, funding (or lack thereof) did come up. We were told that a particular "basket"  of funding would be running out very soon. This would mean that the work would continue but at an extremely slowed pace. The slowdown would NOT affect or extend the consent agreement timeline that EPA has with the City of New York regarding the April 2020 deadline for the city to acquire the properties they wish to either purchase or seize at the head of the canal for the required retention tank placement.  But a slowdown in general should be expected and of course, a slowdown is never welcome.


Shortly after that on March 30th, to be exact, EPA issued the following statement:

"Work on the Gowanus Canal is expected to continue using funding that the EPA already has and, as is the goal of the Superfund program, relying on the work being conducted by those parties responsible for the pollution at the site. The regional office has not requested additional funding from EPA's national office.

The EPA currently has several administrative orders in place which ensure the completion of design work and a dredging and capping pilot. Under those orders, work is expected to begin later this year on the pilot in the 4th Street Turning Basin.

2022 remains the EPA estimated target for completion of the dredging work at the Gowanus Canal Superfund site, with work on the Combined Sewer Overflows completed after that."


So, with that good and most welcomed news, things seem to be progressing mostly on schedule.....
(edit) See LINK for rest


Monday, April 3, 2017

The Generation Gap

Today the fire drill in the high school pierced the halls during art making time.  Students ran outside the school building with white plaster bandages still drying on their hands in amusing gestures. Laughing, cursing, giggling the way high school students always do, they headed away from the school.  We "landed" on this corner in front of a house with an obvious artist resident inside.  But only I could see this.  The students could not understand what I found so interesting, even with this little hobby horse sculpture hanging feet from their own faces. This is the generation gap I find myself in so often these days.

T.S.

Sunday, April 2, 2017

Where is America headed these days? Does anyone know?

Where is America headed these days? Does anyone know?
As I was walking past this pile of rocks and the mostly burned out (but once gorgeous) building in the rear, I thought about this. It was all very beautiful once upon a time.  But all I can see now are giant boulders in my way.
 And a flimsy fence meant to keep me out perhaps. T.S.

Saturday, April 1, 2017

Attention All NYC Activists: A New Book on MYC Zoning Laws for You to Read!

Attention NYC Land Use and Development/
Housing/Workspace/Social Justice
Artist/Activists!

Everyone must read this new book! “Zoned Out”
http://www.urpub.org/books/zonedout
Zoned Out! Race, Displacement, and City Planning in New York City
$20.00 
Editors: Tom Angotti and Sylvia Morse
Contributors: Tom Angotti; Philip DePaolo; Peter Marcuse; Sylvia Morse; Samuel Stein

It is critical to read up on the complicated subject of Zoning Laws in NYC if one wants to fight the powers that be!

Friday, March 31, 2017

"A Rezoning Poem" from City Limits


I found this powerful poem just now.  I thought I would post a bit of it here.  I can certainly relate to this writer. And a POEM is surely good one way to express one's profound dismay.  I believe I know someone else who has worked in this genre...
 
(edit)
...."Positive results are made in numbers. We must demand those who are oppose; to assist in…
Preventing the throes of oppression…the people want to abolish pandemic depression.
It is a responsibility to look towards the betterment of all, living in the neighborhood, that we may live peaceably and fairly as we should…and it is only fair for the “Small Businessman” to receive a helping hand…Let him stay! What more can we say..? Can there be another way to persuade the “Powers” behind the system, to make them listen…if they would?
Just listen closely to the cries of everyone, surviving in the neighborhood."

See City Limits for the rest of this poem.

Ijaaza EL-Nuwaubun is a poet who lives in Gowanus.

Thursday, March 30, 2017

The Brooklyn Blogger with the Paul Manafort Scoop

One of Carroll Garden's finest: Katia Kelly, PMFA activist and blogger ('citizen journalist') has a scoop that has gone viral this week! 
Way to go Katia! I
I am sooooo sooooo proud of you and delighted to be your friend/activist buddette!
xxoo t.


http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-brooklyn-neighborhood-blogger-with-the-paul-manafort-scoop

Wednesday, March 29, 2017

Our culture is in YUGE trouble.

Hello, I am featuring this story here NOT to make more "drama" about these two schools where I work as a Professor In Residence or because I advocate violence or hatred or evil acts. 

I am placing it here because I truly feel and know in my gut that the words and deed of 45  and our current political climate are sowing GINORMOUS seeds of despair, anger, and powerlessness in many parts of our society. (Not just in urban school districts). However I feel these places are surely cultural barometers and yes, I happen to work there too.

It does not take a rocket scientist to understand this. And it does not take take a genius to understand that students and the poor and all the "others" will always be the easy scapegoats of the powers that be because these powers that be face so LITTLE blow-back when they profess their many hatreds and accusations. Hatred has become popular in our culture in fact. Hatred is trying to become the new "normal".

And it does not take an art educator to realize that the reactions of A FEW (not the majority by any stretch of any imagination) of these targeted young people in these situations who see and hear and FEEL these cultural hatreds will turn away form rational behaviors and instead issue a warning of their own in their own powerless voice/s in order to try and and have a 'voice' in a culture gone mad. In other words, they emulate the constant bullying and the hatred spewed at them from the powers that be. You see?

Such young people are also excellent "students' after all. But they are learning NOT from the passionate and teachers and administrators and all the many others in the building who are trying so desperately hard to make a difference in these students' lives daily. Nope. Such students are actually learning from their cell phones and their internet culture and all the visual culture and media culture with the blatant and cleverly disguised, constant daily messages of RACISM and and SEXISM and ALL the "ism's based on hate including: TERRORISM now disguised as 'News" and endorsed by the now ruling party.
And if anyone is dumb enough to think that this violent behavior will begin and end in an "urban" public school district, full of many so many "others" (and it is not a problem for ALL SOCIETY) oh, what a YUGE learning curve you now face have to get yourself to any truth. Our culture is in YUGE trouble.

Isn't it time for ALL OF USE to demand a better country and a better world?

Triada Samaras

http://abc7ny.com/news/paterson-students-over-alleged-columbine-like-threat/1823998/ 

PS
And where is Governor Christie in the public education mess in his state and especially in the Paterson School District that is under control of his state? (And that just lost funding for "school security"? I guess Mr. Christie has some other fish to fry http://www.nydailynews.com/.../ally-n-gov-christie...before his hoped for WH drug czar ? appointment....


Sunday, March 26, 2017

Abolish the Board of Standards and Appeals/BSA! by City Councilman Tony Avella

Dateline : Thursday, August 07, 2008

Abolish the Board of Standards and Appeals!
By City Council Member Tony Avella

If the framers of the Constitution/Declaration of
Independence were still alive today, I am confident
they would cite the operation and existence of the
City’s Board of Standards and Appeals (BSA) as a
perfect example of unrepresentative government.

It is time for this unresponsive, undemocratic bureaucratic
body to go!

For many New Yorkers, BSA is a totally unknown entity,
yet its impact is being felt in every neighborhood in this City.
A quasi-judicial agency, BSA is comprised of five
commissioners appointed by the mayor for six-year terms
to, in large part, issue variances to the zoning code.

It is the implementation of this responsibility that has
irked, frustrated and outright angered elected officials,
community boards and residents.

The original mission of BSA was to provide a relief valve
for property owners in those rare circumstances where
existing zoning regulations would prohibit them from
reasonably developing their property. I stress the
word “rare.”

Unfortunately, BSA has been allowed to mushroom into a
huge loophole for developers who want to circumvent
the law. For far too long developers have used BSA as
“an old boys network” where a handful of law firms
represent hundreds of clients/developers trying to
build in excess of existing building and zoning code
requirements.

While the borough presidents and community boards
routinely submit comments on variance applications,
their opinions are only advisory and often dismissed by BSA.

Despite BSA’s assertions to the contrary, borough
president and community board recommendations
are generally only successful in achieving very minor
changes to original plans. It is fascinating to note that
City Council members have no official role in the
process other than to receive a copy of the application.

When reviewing applications, BSA must evaluate the
request in terms of the following five criteria:

* Does the unique condition of the property prevent
reasonable development?
* Would unique property conditions prevent an owner
from obtaining a reasonable financial return?
* Does the variance, if granted, alter the essential
character of the neighborhood?
* Is the situation the result of a self-imposed hardship?
(In other words – you cannot buy a property knowing
the restrictions and then claim hardship.)
* Is the variance requested the minimum necessary
to afford relief?

Unfortunately, BSA routinely disregards these guidelines.
The self-imposed hardship restriction is rarely enforced.
The BSA requirement that the variance will not alter the
character of the neighborhood is a joke! It is never really
considered.

And why does the city, through BSA, reward developers
for making a bad financial decision. If you own any other
type of business in this city and make a bad investment
or your business fails, the city does not bail you out. But,
BSA will grant a financial hardship variance for developers
who make poor judgments or risky investments.

This practice clearly demonstrates the huge political
influence that the real estate industry enjoys in this city.
It is a foolproof system that rescues developers from
their own incompetence and investment mistakes.

To justify their favorable actions towards developers,
BSA will frequently rely on their “quasi-judicial” status
as a defense. This convenient excuse provides political
cover for their lack of common sense and failure to
adhere to the five variance criteria. Yet, the
qualifications for appointment to the board say
nothing about being an attorney.

The only qualifications mentioned in the City Charter
are that one commissioner shall be a registered
architect with at least 10 years’ experience as an
engineer and one shall be a planner with professional
qualifications and with at least 10 years’ experience
as a planner.

Why is there no requirement that the Commissioners
have legal experience? Because it was never meant to
be the final legal arbiter of these land use issues.

Ever since the old Board of Estimate was eliminated, the
only recourse for New Yorkers to appeal BSA decisions is
to file an Article 78 lawsuit against the city – a time consuming
and expensive proposition. Good luck in trying to get
satisfaction by that route!

When the Board of Estimate was in existence, BSA decisions
could be appealed to that legislative body. Under that
system, at least New Yorkers had the opportunity to
press their case for justice before officials elected by the
people as opposed to the appointed bureaucrats on BSA.

Since taking office in January of 2002, I have authored
several pieces of legislation in an attempt to reform this
agency. Unfortunately, all of them are languishing in
the City Council as a direct result of the pressure
exerted by the real estate industry and the opposition
from the Mayor’s Administration.

In order to address the lack of oversight and an
appeal process, I introduced Intro. 261/2006. This
legislation would re-establish the review process over
variance and special permits decisions, previously
held by the former Board of Estimate, under the
auspices of the City Council.

The City Council already has jurisdiction in land use
matters under the Uniform Land Use Review
Procedure (ULURP). Adding this review process
would strengthen the ULURP procedure and add
balance to this area of land use decision-making.

I authored two other bills in a further attempt to
address the total control of the mayor in appointing
members to the board.

Intro. 263/2006, if enacted, would expand the
number of BSA commissioners from five to thirteen,
with the eight additional members to be appointed,
one each, by the borough presidents, public advocate,
comptroller and City Council.

The five mayoral appointees would remain; but their
voices would be tempered by those of the eight additional
members. Obviously, this would enable elected officials to
better serve their constituents by having direct
representation on the board.

As a companion bill to Intro. 263, I introduced Intro.
262/2006, which would require that all variance and
special permit decisions by BSA be made by a
two-thirds majority of the quorum present and voting.
Once the membership of BSA is expanded to 13 members,
requiring a two-thirds majority vote would ensure that
decisions of such magnitude are addressed by a
substantial majority of the board.

This past February, I introduced Intro. 695/2008,
which would require one of the members of BSA to
be a financial analyst with professional qualifications.
Since one of the five variance criteria involves the
review of an alleged financial hardship, it only makes
sense to have a member of the Board who has the
financial background to determine the legitimacy of
any such claim by a developer.

I am also in the process of writing legislation that
would change the statute of limitations for filing
an Article 78 proceeding challenging BSA decisions,
from thirty days to four months.

The current 30-day time frame presents an unnecessarily
harsh procedural hurdle. The very short time frame within
which an Article 78 petition must be filed makes such challenges extremely difficult to execute due to the cost and extensive preparation that is required in bringing these actions before the Supreme Court.

The majority of Article 78 BSA cases are brought by
aggrieved citizens who need a significant amount of
time to come up with funds to retain counsel, and for
counsel to properly prepare the necessary petitions and
accompanying documents that must be filed. Making this
change in the law would provide residents and community
groups the necessary time to properly develop and file an
Article 78.

The passage of any of these bills would make a
significant impact on how BSA operates and allow for
additional community input and a more balanced
decision making process.
Having said that, I have come to believe that BSA
decisions are so skewed in favor of developers that
the entire system must be scrapped.

After personally testifying before the board on
numerous variance applications on behalf of the community,
not only those within my City Council district, but other neighborhoods/boroughs as well, I have come to realize
that the entire process is a charade.

It is extremely disheartening to watch neighborhood
residents travel to the BSA office in lower Manhattan
for hearing after hearing to contest a variance application,
only to see the commissioners vote in unison to approve the application.

It has become a BSA routine; whereby multiple hearings are
held on an item until; it would appear, the community is
simply worn down. It is almost impossible for the average
person to continuously take time off from work or other
duties to fight the developers.

In the final analysis, while most people do not know
this
agency even exists, it has had and continues to have
a
dramatic and damaging effect on the residential
character of neighborhoods throughout our city by
allowing developers to circumvent the zoning – in many
cases ruining the quality of
life for millions of New Yorkers. It is time to end
this sham and close what is the biggest loophole for
developers.


Abolish the Board of Standards and Appeals!

“Abolish the Board of Standards and Appeals!”
pub. in the Queens
Ledger by Tony Avella 8/7/2008.